Skip to main content

Learn how Lilli Health is shaping the future of PCOS wellness. Learn More



The Hidden Dangers of Whey Protein

Whey protein has become a staple in the fitness and health industry, touted for its muscle-building and recovery benefits. However, if you’re concerned about high insulin levels, particularly if you have conditions like PCOS, it’s important to understand the implications of consuming whey protein. Studies have shown that whey protein can spike insulin levels even higher than a slice of white bread, making it a problematic choice for many. 

Why Does Whey Protein Spike Insulin? 

Let’s start by remembering that the basic biological purpose of whey protein is to promote rapid growth in a newborn baby or newborn animal. Milk naturally contains insulin and insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1), which also facilitates this rapid growth. During the cheese and yogurt making process, whey is separated from casein, and this liquid whey retains much of the naturally present insulin and IGF-1.  

But the insulin-spiking effects of whey don’t stop there. Whey protein is rich in branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs), which are known to stimulate insulin secretion. While BCAAs are essential amino acids necessary for muscle growth and repair, overconsumption can lead to insulin resistance. Regular consumption of whey protein often results in the overconsumption of BCAAs, contributing to high insulin levels and metabolic issues over time. 

A quick Google search will reveal research touting whey protein’s ability to force the pancreas to secrete extra insulin as a potential treatment for type 2 diabetes. The idea is that by stimulating more insulin production, blood sugar levels can be better controlled in the short term. However, this approach is short-sighted and fails to consider the long-term health effects of excess insulin secretion. Over time, chronic high insulin levels can lead to insulin resistance, worsening metabolic health and increasing the risk of other conditions such as type 2 diabetes, heart disease, and cancer. It’s crucial to look beyond immediate blood sugar control and consider the overall impact on the body’s metabolic system. 

Isn’t Whey Protein Healthy? 

Health and fitness enthusiasts often consume large amounts of whey protein, but this doesn’t mean they are immune to the potential negative effects of high insulin levels. First, it’s important to understand that metabolism varies significantly from person to person. While some weightlifters may be lean or healthy despite consuming whey protein, others are not. However, appearances can be deceiving; someone may be lean because they don’t produce enough insulin, which prevents them from storing fat easily. You can’t judge someone’s health based solely on their diet and assume the same approach will work for you.  

Bodybuilders and fitness enthusiasts often time their whey protein intake to coincide with workouts, using the insulin spikes to drive nutrients into their cells for muscle repair and growth. For the average person, consuming whey protein after low-impact exercises like walking can lead to excessive insulin spikes without the intended benefits. 

Even for those who consume whey protein after strength training, it’s important to note that you don’t need whey protein to achieve an insulin spike. In fact, it’s causing more harm than good over the long term. Consuming whole food proteins can provide a more moderate release of insulin, offering the same muscle-building benefits without the potential health risks associated with excessive insulin secretion.  

The Ubiquity of Whey Protein in Our Food Supply 

Whey protein is everywhere, and its prevalence is no accident. Originally a waste product from cheese and yogurt production, manufacturers had to find a way to dispose of it. The solution? Market it as a high-value health and fitness product. Food manufacturers add whey protein to a wide range of processed products, allowing them to label these items as “high protein” and significantly mark up their prices. 

This marketing strategy is profitable for manufacturers but can be detrimental to consumers, particularly the 89% of the population with high insulin levels, including the 20% of reproductive-age females who have PCOS. Both groups should be cautious about consuming whey protein due to its insulin-spiking properties.  

Healthier Alternatives to Whey Protein 

If you rely on protein powder, there are several alternatives that are less likely to spike your insulin levels: 

  • Egg White Protein: A great source of protein without the insulin spikes associated with whey. 
  • Bone Protein: Another excellent option that provides a complete amino acid profile. 
  • Seed Proteins: Options like hemp seed and pumpkin seed proteins are nutritious and less likely to affect your insulin levels. 

When choosing protein sources, it’s crucial to look closely at labels and avoid processed foods marketed as high protein. The best sources of protein are whole foods that don’t require labels, such as meat, poultry, fish, eggs, nuts, and seeds. For vegetarians and vegans, minimally processed soy products like whole soybeans (edamame) or tofu, as well as nuts and seeds, are ideal protein sources. 


Whey protein, while popular, can have significant drawbacks for those with high insulin levels or conditions like PCOS. Understanding the insulin-spiking nature of whey and its widespread presence in processed foods can help you make more informed dietary choices. Opting for alternative protein sources and focusing on whole, unprocessed foods can support better metabolic health and help you manage insulin levels more effectively. 

For more tips on managing insulin levels and adopting a Low Insulin Lifestyle, visit By making informed dietary choices, you can take control of your health and wellbeing—naturally and effectively.